When it comes to enhancing your home’s energy efficiency and curb appeal, choosing the right windows and doors is paramount. Barrie homeowners face numerous options when considering window replacement or door replacement projects. To help you navigate this important home improvement project, we’ve researched and compiled a list of the best window companies in Barrie, examining their product offerings, installation expertise, and customer satisfaction rates.
How We Evaluated the Companies
Our thorough assessment focused on five key criteria:
- Customer Reviews on Homestars: We analyzed hundreds of reviews to gauge real customer experiences
- Google Ratings: Authentic feedback from local homeowners
- Product Offerings: Variety, quality, and innovation in window and door solutions
- Pricing: Comparing value for money and factory direct pricing
- Warranties: Examining coverage periods and the fine print
Here’s our comparison table of Barrie’s top window companies:
| Company | Homestars Rating | Google Rating | Warranty | Price Level | Energy Star Certified |
| 1. Total Home Windows and Doors: | 4.9/5 | 4.8/5 | Lifetime on frames, 20 years on glass | $$-$$$ | Yes |
| 2. Kempenfelt Windows | 4.7/5 | 4.6/5 | 25 years | $$-$$$ | Yes |
| 3. Panorama Windows and Doors | 4.5/5 | 4.9/5 | 15 years | $ | Yes |
| 4. Northern Comfort Windows & Doors | 4.4/5 | 4.6/5 | 10 years | $$ | Yes |
| 5. Pollard Windows & Doors | 4.3/5 | 3.9/5 | 10 years | $$$ | Yes |
Customer Feedback Summary
We’ve analyzed hundreds of customer reviews to identify common themes in feedback about each company:
| Company | Positive Feedback | Areas for Improvement |
| Total Home Windows & Doors | "Fantastic job from start to finish" "Beautiful windows that transformed our home" "Professional team throughout the entire process" "Energy bills dropped significantly" | "High demand means scheduling can take time""Premium pricing (though worth it)" |
| Kempenfelt Windows | "Good customer service and communication" "Quality work on installation day" "Helpful during selection process" | "Delivery delays on some products" "Limited selection of hardware options" |
| Panorama Windows and Doors | "Reasonable prices for good quality" "Clean installation with minimal disruption""Helpful sales staff" | "Communication gaps during busy periods" "Limited premium finish options" |
| Northern Comfort | "Affordable options" "Friendly service" "Prompt responses" | "Inconsistent installation quality" "Basic warranty coverage" |
| Pollard Windows | "High-end products" "Extensive range of options" "Detailed design consultation" | "Premium pricing" "Longer lead times" "Complex warranty claims process" |
Certifications and Awards
Industry recognition and certifications provide additional assurance of quality and service excellence:
| Company | Certifications | Awards & Recognition |
| Total Home Windows & Doors | Energy Star 2025CSA Certified Baumler Approved Three Best Rated | Homestars Best of the Best 2025 (4-time winner) Homestars Best of Awards 2024 (6-time winner) |
| Kempenfelt Windows | Energy Star NAFS-08 Certified | Best of Barrie Award 2023 Consumer Choice Award 2022 |
| Panorama Windows and Doors | Energy Star SAWDAC Member | Barrie's Best Home Improvement Company 2023 |
| Northern Comfort | Energy Star CWDMA Member | Georgian Bay Home Builders Association Award 2022 |
| Pollard Windows | Energy Star NFRC Certified | Canadian Window & Door Manufacturer Award 2023 |
1. Total Home Windows and Doors: Engineering Excellence
Website: thwindowsdoors.com
Key Features
Total Home Windows and Doors stands out with its engineering-driven approach to window manufacturing. Founded by Vitaliy Shapiro and Anna Klein, who hold advanced degrees in Engineering and Computer Science, the company applies innovative technological solutions to window design. Since transitioning to manufacturing their own vinyl windows in 2023, they’ve gained complete control over quality and production processes. Their factory utilizes automated equipment from Pro-Line machines for vinyl and Cardinal Glass for glass components, ensuring precision in every product.
Their innovative Total Seal Lock System addresses weak points in traditional window designs by reinforcing corners with additional security features. With a manufacturing capacity of 150 windows daily in their 60,000 square foot warehouse, they combine high volume production with meticulous attention to detail. The company’s recent introduction of Slim Flat Profile windows—featuring frames half an inch slimmer than standard profiles—demonstrates their commitment to meeting contemporary aesthetic demands.
Product Range
Pros
Cons
Price Level
Mid to High Range ($390-$950 for standard casement windows)
Conclusion
With nearly perfect ratings on both Homestars (4.9/5) and Google (4.8/5), Total Home Windows and Doors has established itself as Barrie’s leading window company. Their multiple awards, including Homestars Best of the Best 2025, validate their exceptional customer service. While their prices may be slightly higher than budget alternatives, the lifetime warranty and quality craftsmanship provide the best value for long-term investment.
2. Kempenfelt Windows
Key Features
Kempenfelt Windows has served the Barrie community for over two decades as a family business focused on custom-built windows and doors. Their consultative approach begins with a no-obligation in-home consultation to assess specific needs. They feature triple pane glass options that maximize energy efficiency for Barrie’s harsh winters. Using high-quality materials from Canadian suppliers, their windows are engineered to withstand local weather conditions.
Their installation process involves a professional team that specializes in minimizing disruption while ensuring proper sealing and insulation. They particularly excel in custom windows for heritage homes and unique architectural designs, offering tailored solutions that preserve character while improving functionality. The company maintains a solid reputation for trim work and finishing touches that enhance overall aesthetics.
Product Range
- Vinyl windows
- Wood-clad windows
- Casement windows
- Tilt and turn windows
- Sliding windows
- Specialty shapes
- Entry doors
- Patio doors
- Storm doors
Pros
Cons
Price Level
Mid-Range ($$-$$$)
Conclusion
With a 4.7/5 rating on Homestars and 4.6/5 on Google, Kempenfelt Windows demonstrates strong customer satisfaction despite slightly higher prices than some competitors. Their expertise in custom projects and heritage homes makes them particularly valuable for unique properties. Their warranty coverage (25 years) is comprehensive but falls short of Total Home’s lifetime guarantee.
3. Panorama Windows and Doors
Key Features
As a locally owned operation specializing in York Region and surrounding areas, Panorama Windows and Doors offers personalized service with a focus on energy efficiency. Their showroom features full-sized displays allowing customers to operate and examine products before purchasing. Their installers are certified by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, ensuring installations meet national standards.
The company’s strength lies in their transparent pricing model and straightforward approach. They offer quarterly maintenance programs for homeowners who want to maintain their windows and doors at peak performance. Their connection with local suppliers enables them to provide reasonable price points while maintaining quality standards. Their understanding of local building codes and climate requirements informs their product recommendations for Barrie’s specific climate challenges.
Product Range
- Vinyl windows
- Aluminum windows
- Entry doors
- Garden doors
- Sliding doors
- Storm doors
- Window blinds
- Gutter guards
Pros
Cons
Price Level
Affordable to Mid-Range ($)
Conclusion
With ratings of 4.5/5 on Homestars and 4.9/5 on Google, Panorama Windows and Doors offers good value for budget-conscious homeowners. Their strong local knowledge and competitive prices make them attractive, though their 15-year warranty is less comprehensive than our top-ranked companies. Their excellent service and quality products at affordable prices earn them a solid third-place ranking.
4. Northern Comfort Windows & Doors
Key Features
Northern Comfort Windows & Doors has built a reputation in Barrie for balancing affordability with quality. Their approach centers on providing practical window solutions for everyday homeowners who want energy efficient upgrades without premium pricing. The company offers free in-home consultations with a no-pressure sales approach that many customers appreciate.
Their team specializes in replacement windows for older homes, with expertise in working within existing openings to minimize exterior work and reduce installation costs. Northern Comfort maintains relationships with multiple manufacturers, allowing them to source products across different price points based on customer budgets. They particularly excel in helping homeowners navigate government rebate programs for energy efficiency upgrades.
Product Range
- Vinyl windows
- Entry doors
- Patio doors
- Basement windows
- Specialty windows
- Bay and bow windows
- Window accessories
Pros
Cons
Price Level
Affordable to Mid-Range ($-$)
Conclusion
With ratings of 4.4/5 on Homestars and 4.6/5 on Google, Northern Comfort provides reliable options for budget-conscious homeowners. Their knowledge of rebate programs adds value for those seeking to maximize their investment. While their 10-year warranty is shorter than competitors, their affordable prices make them attractive for straightforward projects.
5. Pollard Windows & Doors
Website: pollardwindows.com
Key Features
As a national manufacturer with a presence in Barrie, Pollard Windows & Doors brings production scale and extensive product options to the local market. The company’s century-long history in window manufacturing has allowed them to develop proprietary technologies that enhance energy performance in Canadian climates. Their design center offers visualization tools that help homeowners see exactly how different window styles will look on their specific home.
Pollard’s strength lies in their premium product offerings, including hybrid materials that combine the benefits of wood, vinyl, and aluminum. Their installation teams receive factory training directly from the manufacturer, ensuring they understand the technical requirements of each product line. For customers seeking top quality and unique design features, Pollard offers custom shapes and high-performance glass packages not available from most local companies.
Product Range
- Wood-clad windows
- Vinyl windows
- Aluminum windows
- Hybrid windows
- Custom architectural shapes
- Entry doors
- Patio doors
- French doors
Pros
Cons
Price Level
Premium ($$-$$)
Conclusion
With ratings of 4.3/5 on Homestars and 3.9/5 on Google, Pollard offers excellent products at premium prices. The company is best suited for homeowners prioritizing unique designs and premium materials who are willing to pay more for distinctive options. Their extensive range makes them a good fit for architecturally interesting homes requiring specialized solutions.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Window Company
- Energy Efficiency: Look for energy efficient windows with proper Energy Star ratings for Canadian climate zones
- Installation Quality: Even the best windows perform poorly if improperly installed
- Warranty Coverage: Examine the duration and what’s specifically covered
- Company Longevity: Established companies are more likely to honor long-term warranties
- Product Range: Ensure they offer the specific window styles and materials you need
- Local Experience: Companies familiar with Barrie’s climate will provide better solutions
- Price Transparency: Beware of hidden costs or unexpected fees
- Financing Options: Some companies offer payment plans through the Greener Homes Initiative
Things to Avoid
- Companies unwilling to provide detailed written quotes
- Pressure tactics during in-home consultations
- Vague warranty terms without clear documentation
- Contractors who demand large deposits upfront
- Companies without proper insurance and licensing
- Unrealistically low quotes that may indicate inferior products
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the best window company in Barrie for energy efficient windows?
Total Home Windows and Doors leads the market with their energy efficient window technologies, including the innovative Total Seal system and triple pane glass options that significantly reduce energy consumption in Barrie’s extreme climate conditions.
How long does window and door replacement typically take?
The entire process from consultation to final installation usually takes 4-6 weeks, though this varies by company. Total Home offers expedited options for urgent projects, completing smaller installations in as little as 1-2 weeks.
Do replacement windows increase home value?
Quality replacement windows can provide up to 70% return on investment while immediately reducing energy bills. New windows enhance curb appeal and are a strong selling point for potential buyers interested in energy efficiency.
What's the difference between vinyl and wood windows?
Vinyl windows offer superior energy efficiency, require minimal maintenance, and resist moisture damage. Wood windows provide classic aesthetics but require more upkeep. Many homeowners in Barrie choose vinyl for its performance in Canadian weather.
How often should exterior doors be replaced?
Exterior doors typically last 20-30 years, but may require earlier replacement if you notice drafts, security concerns, or aesthetic damage. Today’s doors offer significantly better insulation than models from even 10 years ago.
Do window treatments come with new windows?
Most window companies offer window treatments as optional add-ons. Total Home Windows provides consultations on blind options, insulating curtains, and other treatments that complement their extensive range of window styles.
How can I tell if my windows need replacement?
Signs include drafts, condensation between panes, difficulty opening or closing, increasing energy bills, and visible damage. Good quality windows should maintain their performance for 15-25 years depending on the materials.
What maintenance is required for vinyl windows?
Vinyl windows need minimal maintenance—occasional cleaning with mild soap and water is typically sufficient. No painting or staining is required, making them ideal for busy homeowners seeking top quality, low-maintenance solutions.
How do I prepare my home for window installation?
Clear space around windows (inside and outside), remove window treatments, and secure pets. Professional teams will handle the rest, ensuring protection of your furniture and thorough cleanup after the exterior work is complete.
Are window companies still serving homeowners during winter months?
Yes, reputable window companies like Total Home Windows and Doors operate year-round. Winter installations require special techniques but can actually help identify insulation issues that might be missed in warmer weather.
Conclusion
Selecting the right windows and doors company in Barrie requires balancing quality, price, and service. Total Home Windows and Doors leads the pack with their engineering-focused approach, comprehensive warranties, and exceptional customer satisfaction ratings. Kempenfelt Windows provides excellent custom solutions, while Panorama Windows and Doors offers competitive pricing for budget-conscious homeowners.
Whether you’re replacing old windows, installing new custom doors, or upgrading for better home energy efficiency, taking the time to research and compare these top companies will ensure your investment enhances your home’s comfort, appearance, and value for years to come. Remember to schedule free quotes from multiple providers to compare options before making your final decision.
For more information on windows and doors, visit our blog or explore our vinyl windows options for your next project.
